The New Communitarian Democrat

Obama's Shift Toward Communitarianism - The Daily Beast var _sf_startpt = (new Date()).getTime(); Follow @thedailybeast TUMBLR Home Politics Business Video Entertainment Fashion Books Art Women in the World Newsweek Featured: The Royalist Travel NSA Scandal Newsweek Subscriber Help Politics Beast Content Section Obama's Shift Toward Communitarianism by Gregory Ferenstein Jun 30, 2013 4:45 AM EDT The Obama years have been marked by a sharp turn toward anti-individualist, anti-authoritarian philosophy. Gregory Ferenstein on how he's transforming what it means to be a Democrat.

Barack Obama was never going to be a champion of civil liberties; he leads a very old and quickly growing strain of the Democratic party that prioritizes the collective good over individual rights. This coercively inclusive worldview feels that every business, government agency, country, and citizen has an obligation to contribute to the greater good.

President Barack Obama participates in a town hall-style meeting with young African leaders at the University of Johannesburg in Soweto, June 29, 2013. (Jason Reed/Reuters)

Obama will mandate universal health coverage but let private insurers run the programs, he'll maintain Middle East wars but work with Russia on global nuclear disarmament, expand the education budget but give more resources to union-less charter schools, and build online tools to monitor stimulus spending while collecting phone records of every American.

While this fiercely anti-individualist, anti-authoritarian philosophy goes by many names, political scientists generally refer to it as "communitarianism," named after the decentralized yet collectivist orientation of communities. "In the my wildest dreams, during 18 years of championing communitarianism, I did not expect a presidential candidate to be as strongly identified with this political philosophy as Obama is," gushed George Washington professor of philosophy Amatai Eztioni.

"He is a communitarian," said former Obama advisor Van Jones in an interview with Breitbart News. "I think we’ve overbalanced the individualistic direction and I think he’s trying to rebalance toward communitarianism."

Established liberal institutions have always worried that communitarian optimism was blind to the damage government agencies and big business could exact on society's most vulnerable. The civil libertarian-communitarian internal battle reached it's height following the expansion of the security state after September 11.

"Should we have a new balance post-9/11, and I think the answer to that is absolutely not," said former ACLU president Nadine Strossen in a series of debates with Etzioni in the 2001 ramp-up to the Patriot Act.

Eztioni, in lock-step with Obama 12 years later, had argued that the FBI's new email snooping programs were most justified: "The key issue is not if certain powers – for example, the ability to decrypt email – should or should not be available to public authorities, but whether or not these powers are used legitimately and whether mechanisms are in place to ensure such usage."

Communitarians generally don't fear invasions of privacy, so long as there's sufficient public involvement and oversight.

"For communitarians, public safety generally comes first," University of Southern California professor Brian Rathbun wrote to me in an email. “A key element of Obama's personal philosophy is on the merits of cooperation, that collective enterprises yield greater gains than individual action.”

The obsession with mass collaboration largely explains much of Obama's failing civil liberties record, across the board. All the way back in 1999, a young, higher-pitched Obama called teacher unions "a barrier to change."

As president, he's been an unqualified proponent of experimental charters, which reject the job stability of traditional schools. "In return for this flexibility, we should expect high standards and accountability, and make tough decisions to close charter schools that are underperforming and not improving," Obama declared in in a 2013 proclamation for National Charter Schools week.

To be sure, Obama is no privacy-ignoring, union-suppressing political snowflake. Just a short train ride away, New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg has distinguished himself as a collaboration and drone-happy public servant. "We’re going to have more visibility and less privacy. I don’t see how you stop that,” he admitted in a candid radio interview, where he endorsed blanketing the city with spy drones. "What’s the difference whether the drone is up in the air or on the building? I mean, intellectually I have trouble making a distinction."

Bloomberg has also shown a willingness to crush unions who stand in the way of innovation. He reportedly threatened to "fucking destroy" the taxi industry, which staunchly opposes car sharing technology startups such as Uber, that allow people to use their own cars as cabs. "It's the old entrenched industries that try to use the shield of regulation," Bloomberg told me during a press conference in San Francisco, "to protect them from the kind of competition that benefits society."

Closing the door on civil liberties, however, has opened up some exciting opportunities for novel, bipartisan policy-making. For instance, Obama supported a little known "waiver for state innovation" in the Affordable Health Care Act that exempts any state from the new law, so long as they can cover just as many people without increasing costs. This coercive form of mass collaboration admits that the federal government doesn't always have the best ideas, but keeps vulnerable citizens from being left without care.

"In the my wildest dreams, during 18 years of championing communitarianism, I did not expect a presidential candidate to be as strongly identified with this political philosophy as Obama is."

Already, Obamacare's requirement that private insurers disclose their costs has lead to dramatic cuts to Oregon healthcare prices.

Obama also championed new forms of national service, tripling the number of young volunteers in the AmeriCorp program, from 75,000 to 250,000. Additionally, his newly appointed Chief Technology officer, Todd Park, convinced major technology firms to volunteer a total of a million new student mentors by 2020, which could dramatically increase minority student involvement in STEM.

In international relations, Obama broke George W. Bush's streak of stalling nuclear weapons disarmament with a ambitious multilateral proposal to slash American and Russian stockpiles by 30 percent, hopefully putting us on the path to a less apocalypse-threatened world.

As this political philosophy begins to displace traditional liberals, it should be known that communitarians are a fairly easy bunch to spot – just look for notions of interdependence and global citizenship.

"For alongside our famous individualism, there's another ingredient in the American saga, a belief that we are all connected as one people. If there's a child on the south side of Chicago who can't read, that matters to me, even if it's not my child," Obama said in his famous 2004 Democratic National Convention speech, which should have tipped off civil libertarians that their age-old communitarian rivals were coming back.

It's also quite easy to spot communitarians based on who their deep-pocketed Silicon Valley donors are backing. While the Bay Area gave more to Obama than either Wall Street (New York) or Hollywood (Los Angeles), they are exceedingly selective with the Democrats they support – and rarely give money to the party itself.

Newark Mayor and senate candidate Cory Booker is a Silicon Valley favorite and has focused the $100 million education donation he got from Mark Zuckerberg on controversial charter schools. It should be no surprise that the union-less, privacy-skittish social network is itself a communitarian totem.

Legally, Facebook has aggressively fought regulations to deny it's ability to automatically enroll users in new products ("opt-in"). Facebook has argued that if users had been required to opt-in to the newsfeed, the initial privacy hysteria would have blunted adoption of a tool that is now a staple of social networking. Just like in a community, participation and sharing are the default assumption; privacy and isolation are left as inconvenient, anti-social options.

Together with their friends in Silicon Valley, communitarians are becoming a dominant force in society. To the extent that readers optimistically believe that cooperation between foreign governments, big business, and everyday citizens can yield collective prosperity, the growing power of the communitarian Democratic party is a welcome change. For those who fear that we live in a zero-sum world between the powerful and weak, communitarians are blindly leading us into an unequal, rights-free society.

Regardless of whether you love or hate them, communitarians are here to stay.

Like The Daily Beast on Facebook and follow us on Twitter for updates all day long.

New author bio: Gregory Ferenstein is the lead writer for
TechCrunch's policy channel, CrunchGov. He also holds a Master's in Mathematical Behavior Sciences.

For inquiries, please contact The Daily Beast at editorial@thedailybeast.com.

Tags: U.S. Politics,Barack Obama,Democrats You Might Also Like Comments Powered by Livefyre Tina Brown: Weiner Helped by Scandal On Wednesday's 'Morning Joe,' the editor-in-chief of Newsweek and the Daily Beast explained why she thinks New York City mayoral candidate Anthony Weiner has benefited from his sex scandal.

Politics Beast Newsletter Available Now! Start your day with the smartest, sharpest takes on all things politics from NewsBeast. Delivered every morning. Sign up now! Thanks! You're subscribed to the newsletter. Sorry! Please try again.

'White House Down' is a Vile Rehash The Best Amphitheaters in America Why Wendy Davis' Filibuster Matters 5 Sports Stars Accused of Killing Someone SCOTUS So Long to DOMA and Prop. 8 Gay Marriage Wins Who can get married now, and where? Eliza Shapiro explains today’s historic Supreme Court decisions.

by Eliza Shapiro Good News, Bad News Not to Be a Downer, but ... by Adam Winkler Payday The Gay Tax Bonanza by Daniel Gross Man On the Run Snowden Makes His Move If Snowden does apply for asylum in Ecuador, it would lead to legal questions with little precedent should the U.S. apply to have him returned. Eli Lake and Ben Jacobs report.

by Eli Lake, Ben Jacobs Transient Leaker Why Strongmen Love Snowden by Michael Moynihan WikiWar WikiLeaks Has Some Chutzpah by Stuart Stevens On the Run Snowden Leaves Hong Kong for Moscow by Anna Nemtsova Foreign Intelligence FBI Looks for Leaks at Secret Court by Eli Lake Stories We Like Wonderwall Stars React to Prop 8 Rulings Mental Floss 10 Questions Still Baffling Scientists Your Tango Divorced Dads: The Unspoken Workplace Discrimination Wonderwall All Apologies: How Stars Say They're Sorry Your Tango 10 Kick-Ass Pick-Up Lines For Online Daters The Cut The Preferred Fashions of Cheating Women Rolling Stone The Last Mystery of the Financial Crisis Pop Sugar Shirtless Men of Summer Rolling Stone The 10 Dumbest Things Ever Said About Gay Marriage Force-Feeding, Step by Step Hunger strikers at Guantanamo Bay are being kept alive with a painful, ethically questionable, and politically sensitive procedure. Here, in excruciating detail, is how it works.

by Michael Keller, Clarisa Diaz, Abby Haglage

How Patrick Leahy Made Sure The Senate Is Going To Pass Immigration Reform Paula Deen Book Sales Climb To No. 1 On Amazon 27 Subtitles That Have Gone Awesomely Wrong What Steve Harvey Looks Like On Vacation G8 Summit Gone Wild Getty; AP (3) The leaders of the world's eight wealthiest countries reunited at the Lough Erne golf resort in Enniskillen, Northern Ireland, this week for a G8 summit they'll never forget ... and perhaps always regret.... Matt Dunham/AP When this gang gets together, you never know what will happen.... Ben Stansall/AFP/Getty British Prime Minister David Cameron is awfully excited to be reunited at long last with German Chancellor Angela Merkel.  View Full Gallery  

When the G8 leaders get together, there is one guarantee: awkward photos. See the best of the 2013 summit.

Prev Next View Full Gallery More

Someone Online Said This is Feminist Crap, So of Course, Now You Need See Why They're Wrong If A Graffiti Artist And A History Teacher Had A Baby, It Would Be This Video Photographer, Tired Of Fashion, Reframes His Idea Of Beauty — With Gorgeous Results Other News Politics Bonus Quote of the Day NSA Leaker Portrayed as a Hero on Russian TV Quote of the Day Get More from Political Wire Entertainment Duh, ‘The Heat’ is going to be a hit. Now what? This Week on Stage: Cirque du Soleil takes on Michael Jackson, plus new fall shows ‘Mad Men’: Will it really end in 1969? Get More from EW.com Entertainment Get More from Buzz Feed Entertainment Week in Photos for June 29, 2013 Celebs who take photos of the paps Ashley Greene adopts a pair of pups, plus more celeb TwitPics! Get More from Wonderwall The Daily Beast Help About Contact Us Jobs Advertise Privacy Community Policy Terms of Use Financial Disclaimer Copyright & Trademark Sections: Home Election Entertainment Books Video Women in the World Press Newsweek Subscribe – 1Mth Free Featured: The Royalist Travel NSA Scandal Newsweek Subscriber Help Partners: Expedia Hotels Hotwire Merchantcircle Reference Thesaurus Urbanspoon Weather data provided by Weather Underground, Inc. Switch to Mobile © 2013 The Newsweek/Daily Beast Company LLC Get Email Updates Sign Up Sign up for daily email updates from The Daily Beast Rubric if (typeof stLight != 'undefined') { stLight.options({publisher:'3d9f370c-ec3a-4248-b23b-c041cc77078e', onhover:false}); }else{ $.error("Share this could not be loaded: stLight was null"); }

View the original article here